Sweet, Velvety Lemon Ice Cream with Gluten-Free Cookies. The Lemon Cookie flavor strikes a balance between sweet and tart with a base of sweet, creamy lemon ice cream mixed with gluten-free buttery shortbread cookies (baked with Straus Organic European Style Unsalted Butter). The mouthfeel resembles homemade, hand-churned ice cream. Straus Family Creamery Organic Lemon Cookie Ice Cream begins with premium organic milk and organic cream. We don’t use any preservatives, fillers, artificial ingredients, or coloring agents in our ice cream. You can taste the difference.